Prairie Pizza
When driving through Murdo, South Dakota, there’s a stop that no pizza lover should miss—Prairie Pizza. Tucked away on W 5th St, this cozy spot has earned a reputation for its warm atmosphere and unforgettable pizza. Offering a variety of flavors, exceptional service, and a menu that balances comfort with creativity, it’s a must-try for anyone passing through.
Unique Menu Highlights
Prairie Pizza stands out for its creative offerings and welcoming menu. Their pizza, made with homemade tomato sauce, is the star of the show. Customers rave about the distinctive, nontraditional crusts, such as the cinnamon-sugar crust that turns a regular pizza into a unique dessert experience, often paired with frosting for extra indulgence. With options for every preference, from savory to sweet, Prairie Pizza has a variety of pizzas that are always fresh and served piping hot. For those craving something more than just pizza, they also offer a range of beverages, including their specialty latte drinks like the indulgent Peppermint Patty, and classic favorites such as Americano and Coke.
On top of the pizza, Prairie Pizza’s menu doesn’t stop there; it also features crunchy potato wedges, perfect for a satisfying snack or side dish. Whether you're sitting down for a casual meal or grabbing something to go, the variety and quality of the menu make it a spot worth visiting time and time again.
A Cozy Yet Versatile Dining Experience
Despite being a small restaurant, Prairie Pizza offers more than just a meal; it creates a memorable dining experience. The cozy interior, designed with a classy yet quiet ambiance, is ideal for both intimate dinners and group gatherings. It’s also family-friendly, with options to accommodate kids. The owner, who often interacts with customers, ensures a personalized touch to your visit.
For those who prefer to dine outdoors, Prairie Pizza offers outdoor seating where you can enjoy your meal in the fresh air, making it perfect for pleasant weather days. Whether you're in the mood to stay and relax, or grab your food to go, Prairie Pizza is flexible, offering takeout and delivery services to suit your needs. The added convenience of Wi-Fi and the option to pay via Apple Pay or credit cards ensures that your visit will be smooth and modern.
Services and Amenities
Beyond the delicious food, Prairie Pizza provides a range of services that elevate the overall experience. They accept reservations, making it easy to plan your visit, and their catering services are perfect for parties or larger events. For those who prefer not to dine in, the restaurant offers both takeout and delivery. Prairie Pizza accepts credit cards and Apple Pay, ensuring payment is convenient and modern.
Moreover, the restaurant's cozy, yet classy vibe is complemented by the availability of TVs for entertainment and the convenience of bike parking for those traveling by two wheels.
Prairie Pizza’s attention to detail in both its food and its services creates a welcoming environment for everyone, from casual diners to families and groups. Whether you’re just passing through or looking for a local favorite, this small yet mighty pizza joint offers a memorable experience that’s not easily forgotten.
Reviews
This may very well be the best pizza I've ever eaten. The homemade tomato sauce made all the difference! I'm sad I was only passing through and may never have a chance to of there again. Definitely worth the stop in Murdo!
The last time we were here was 2013 with our kids, on the way home from Yellowstone. We just happened upon this place then, but the pizza was so good that my husband and I stopped here again on our way back from another road trip. We waited 1.5 hours for it to open, and I ended up having a great chat with the owner while we waited for our order. What makes this pizza so amazing is the non-traditional dough and the cinnamon crust which you dip in the side of frosting. IT'S SO GOOD! Murdo is a small town, and this place was an unexpected find that will always keep us coming back!
In the area for work and after a late flight into Pierre, this was the only option open in Murdo for a late night dinner. We walked in and Prairie Pizza was being single-handedly ran by a one woman team, she was cranking out some orders and let us know she'd be with us shortly, and that she was closing soon, so we could still order carry out. We placed a build your own with pepperoni and mushroom, got 2 drinks and waited in the main area for the pizza to be ready. She gave us napkins and plates to go, handed us our pizza and we headed outdoor to the lighted and we'll manicured lawn with picnic tables. The temp was just right that evening and we enjoyed our pizza outside. The pizza flavor was great, it was fresh, hot out of the oven so toppings were sliding everywhere, but still good after we let it sit for a minute. The interesting thing about this pizza is that it's advertised as a entree and desert at the same time...and it was, and we didn't pay too much attention to that, so it was a little bit of a surprise that the crust had cinnamon rolled into it, and the pie included dipping cups of icing. I am the person who lives for pizza crust, so not having that extra crunchy bite of carbs after finishing the slice was a little disappointing. We felt adventurous, the crust was not sweet, but normal, just rolled like a cinnamon roll, and it turned out to be a nice little combo. Definitely worth a try, a lot of the restaurants in this area were closed or closed early due to staffing. I would support this establishment again.
We found this little slice of heaven (see what I did there?) while stopping for gas in the little town of Murdo, SD. There was a billboard for it a little ways down the highway and it was easy to get there from the interstate. The claim to fame here is that sugar and cinnamon are baked into the edge of the crust and the pizza is served with vanilla icing. So you eat the pizza normally, then dip crust into the icing for baked-in (did it again) dessert. Staff was pleasant if not necessarily outwardly friendly, and because the place was filled with Mask Deniers, we opted to sit outside and they were nice enough to bring the pizza out to our table. The pizza was very good and the leftover pieces remained tasty over the next couple days, even cold. The main reason for four stars instead of five is really the lack of masks and other sanitary precautions that were not in observance here at all.
Dinner and dessert in 1 pizza! The crust is cinnamon and sugar and a bottle Of frosting to go with. Lots of options of good pizza to choose from -and super hot! The owner took our order and made sure we had what we needed. It's a small restaurant with a couple tables and had lots of take outs.